Thursday, March 15, 2007

What It's Like

You worry about how other people describe you. Are you "the heavyset girl"? Are you "larger"? "Overweight"? "Kinda big"? Are you, god forbid, "chunky"?

You look at other fat people and wonder if you are as fat, more fat, or less fat than they are. You look at hugely obese people and feel superior to them, until you remember you may one day become them. You wonder if you look as uncomfortable in your own skin.

You divide the world into Thin and Not Thin. You feel solidarity with the Not Thin, and vague distrust of the Thin.

You are hyperaware of every fat character on TV or in movies or in books. You see how they are portrayed-- lonely, desperate, and marginal. The rare positive portrayal makes you feel amazed and grateful. It feels like a reprieve.

You hate Renee Zellweger for talking about how "fat" she got for Bridget Jones. You hate Elizabeth Hurley for bashing Marilyn Monroe. You hate Gwyneth Paltrow for Shallow Hal. You hate that Jack Black is considered a sex symbol, while Mia Tyler is "Liv Tyler's fat sister." Of course, you love Queen Latifah.

You hate how the words "fat" and "ugly" are so often synonymous. You almost like the phrase "fat and ugly" because it implies the possibility of "fat and beautiful."

Your thin friend breaks up with someone and you don't really feel sorry for her. You know that you're the "fat friend" and she's the "skinny girl." It's the fat friend who can never get a date; the skinny girl can have whoever she wants. She gets Hugh Grant, and you'd be lucky to get Nick Nolte.

You know that no matter if you have "such a pretty face" or "a good personality," the majority of people won't look past your double chin and your flabby arms to figure that out.

You are the only one who seems to notice that Nicole Kidman looks like a chicken.

You browse personals ads, and every guy who specifies his preference for "slender" women (or "in-shape" or "athletic") makes you feel rejected. Every guy who says he wants a larger woman, you suspect of being a creepy fat fetishist. You know that no normal guy wants somebody just like you.

You hate Carnie Wilson. You hate every magazine article featuring Carnie fucking Wilson and how thin she is and how pretty she looks and how much she loves herself now. You think to yourself, "weight loss surgery is such a cop-out."

And then you think, "I wish I could afford it."

You cringe every time you are about to look at photos of yourself. You know what's coming--the inevitable picture where you look like an enormous cow and your friends say, "Oh, what a great picture of you!"

You worry about things that nobody else worries about. Fitting inside the booth at dinner. Being too fat for the amusement park rides. Sitting on your friend's couch and hearing a funny noise. Not being able to climb out of the backseat of a tiny car. Chafing.

Skinny people who complain about how they need to lose five pounds? You hate them. Slightly overweight people complaining about how fat they are? You hate them. You know it's irrational. You hate them anyway.

You feel uncomfortable anytime you hear a fat joke. You feel like it happens constantly. You feel like fat jokes are an acceptable form of cruelty. You see them everywhere.

People say things to you all the time. People yell, "Jenny Craig!" and "Wilson Phillips!" at you on the street. Little kids say, "Mommy, that lady's fat!" Even in foreign countries where fat is more acceptable, you hear, "You're a very beautiful lady but how much do you weigh?!" The worst part is, you're never alone when it happens. Other people hear it too, and all you can do is pretend like hell you didn't hear a thing. And you know your friends are standing there thinking, "I hope she didn't hear that..."

Then later you wish you had told them off. You wish you had turned to them and said, "Oh, are you saying I'm fat? Oh my god! I'm FAT?? I had NO IDEA! Thank god you were here to enlighten me!" Or maybe just ask them very quietly, "Why did you just say that? Was that supposed to be funny? How is that funny?" Or even an offhand, "Fuck you, asshole!" Maybe said with a laugh, like you don't even care.

You never see a body like yours portrayed as sexy or attractive. Not anywhere. Not by anyone. You stop believing you are sexy or attractive.

You hate anything that calls attention to your size. Trying on friends' clothes, putting on seat belts and having to adjust them, a muscular friend who can pick you up but can't lift you very far off the ground. A dozen things a day, it seems.

You hate to eat or drink in front of anyone. You are afraid you will be judged as pathetic if you eat a salad, or a disgusting pig if you eat a cheeseburger. All you know is, your choices will be judged. You're fat. Food is your enemy.

You wish you were invisible.

* * *

This is not me.

Don't get me wrong: I have felt all of those ways listed above. I have had all of those experiences. But that paints a very bleak picture of a very depressing life, and you all know that's not the way I do things around here.

I do have, however, an inner fat girl. She is the part of me that hates my body-- even my new, slimmer body. She is responsible for the times I look in the mirror and see unattractive bulges instead of womanly curves. She is the one doing the constant compare-and-contrast. She makes me tired.

Since the beginning of the year, I have been losing weight. I have gotten ever-closer to being the normal sized person I want to be, who doesn't have to struggle with these issues. But I also feel like I have betrayed my inner fat girl. I have betrayed her, and I am running away from her, because she makes me sad.

There's an alternative--I just don't know how to get there. I don't know how to convince her that she's wrong about everything. I don't know how to tell her that she was beautiful all along.

22 Comments:

Melinda said...

I think your inner fat girl and my inner fat girl went to camp together because they think a lot alike.

3:42 PM  
Jana said...

This is a beautifully written post.

Even skinny girls have an inner "something" girl...fat, ugly, not-good-enough...

I think you've put that feeling into words.

8:06 PM  
Mal said...

What's so great about this post (and it is a really, really great post) is that it doesn't just stop with the standard "what it's like" repertoire that so many of us relate to. (I myself would say that I have had 97.8% of the thoughts you list, and most of them frequently.) The great thing is that you take it one step further and ask questions about what to do when the mindset no longer really applies. Damn. Good questions. Good thoughts. Thanks for sharing.

11:27 PM  
Tessie said...

Thanks for helping us all to remember that we can have those thoughts, but then we can also stop, add the mental

********

...and say THIS IS NOT ME.

Lovely post.

6:24 AM  
Denise said...

i also think nicole kidman looks like a chicken...

6:25 AM  
Kari said...

That was an amazing post. It so captures what all of us feel at some point or another. Thank you for sharing.

11:17 AM  
Natalie C. said...

I really thought that first voice was me (and I thought it was going to be you) until you said it wasn't you, and I realized it wasn't really me, either. Thank you for this identity lesson. I needed it. :)

5:59 PM  
Rachel said...

Wow, you nailed a lot of my very own sentiments.

I used to weigh 300 pounds and ended up losing 175 pounds (I've since gained weight). I really, truly couldn't see the reality of myself. I used to play a game with my sister of "Am I as skinny as she is?" just to get an idea of how I looked. I was constantly misjudging clothing sizes.

Even when I got super-skinny though, I constantly felt fat. Body image is gauged not necessarily by the reflection in the mirror as it is the projection of one's own mind. I try to keep that in mind now when I find myself mentally judging skinny girls.

6:04 PM  
Susan said...

The thing is, you never lose your inner fat girl. Every time I see an overweight woman, I'm thinking, "Did I use to be as fat as her?" Sometimes, I'll even ask my husband *cringe*. I wish my inner voice would just STFU.

12:22 PM  
nathie2481 said...

I've been reading your blog for a while now, but never posted a comment before this one. I was really touched by this post, it describes so well the way i sometimes feel that i even had tears welling up in my eyes :) We all have an inner fat girl who pulls us down and makes us feel self-conscious.... I just wish i could overhear her more! Thank you for the great post and great blog

3:10 AM  
Toni said...

Thanks for a great post. I think I went to camp with all the inner fat girls, too, but right now, mine's not an "inner fat girl" - she's right out in front, every day. I'm hoping to move towards the just sometimes "inside voice" fat girl.

2:28 PM  
Bathsheba Freud said...

I've struggled with this myself. How can i not betray the fat kid that i was? By wanting to be different from her, isn't that yet another slap in her face? Aren't i colluding with all those people who rejected her?

How can I work together with her? For a start, I've realised that she didn't want to be eating as a substitute for activity. She would often prefer to be active and running around having fun than eating. The eating came because her emotions were ignored, not because she was intrinsically fat. I don’t think you betray yourself by changing, or following your own goals. The “betrayal” happens when you don’t listen to the cry for help. I put “betrayal” in inverted commas because I think the reason why you don’t listen at the time is that you don’t know how to, or you can’t listen for your own survival reasons, you haven’t been taught to listen or learnt how to understand emotions yet. So in that case it’s not really a betrayal, it’s just the best you can manage in the circumstances.

It doesn’t sound like you are rejecting your inner fat girl anyway. She sounds like she’s got a pretty creative dialogue going on there!

8:10 PM  
JessiferSeabs said...

Wonderful post. I totally relate to it. My fat never defined me... I was happy, successful, attractive, despite the fat. True, I am happier, healthier, more successful and more attractive withOUT the fat, but I'll never say that being fat ruined my life.

I think it's okay to acknowledge that the fat girl was also beautiful... in fact, what I try to do is make this about HEALTH more than fat. Because you don't ever have to feel a sense of betrayal, shame, guilt, etc. over wanting to be HEALTHIER.

And even though I wasn't doing 8-balls in the bathroom or having heart attacks, there's no way that at 250 lbs and a sedentary smoker, I was anywhere near as healthy as I am now, at 183 lbs, training for a marathon, and sort of a healthfood nut.

7:19 AM  
jen said...

Academy Awards red carpet = chicken coop.

11:47 AM  
Stella Maris said...

Comparing Nicole Kidman to a chicken is a bit insulting to some of the fluffy, gorgeous chickens out there. She is very pointy. I would say she is more like an affronted heron. (Thanks to Douglas Adams for that one.)

And I agree with the others-this is an amazing post. Exceptionally insightful. Thank you, thank you.

2:59 PM  
Rosemary Grace said...

You are not alone: my husband thinks Nicole Kidman looks like a chicken! A pale and sickly chicken at that.

11:18 AM  
Ari said...

I think I can replace "fat" with "disabled" and repost this post, because....damn.

4:02 PM  
Anonymous said...

THanks for one of the best posts I've read in a long time. I am and inner and outer fat girl. One of my favorite statements from well meaning friends is - "I forget that you're heavy because you don't act like you are!" Question - how are fat people supposed to act??!

9:12 AM  
Anonymous said...

Wow that was tremendous! I have had and still have that inner fat girl. I totally relate to everything in that post. The beginning I really related to. I have often said to my friends "am I as big as that person" and then wonder why do I do that to myself, why do I do that to that person that I don't even know who I have just judged by asking that question.

8:36 PM  
Kate said...

I followed a link here, and I'm glad I did. Great post!

2:49 PM  
mo pie said...

Thanks Kate (and everyone!)

5:47 PM  
Ailidh said...

hi there. i just wanted to stop in and say hi, b/c i read your blog nearly 3 years ago when i was actively thinking about losing weight. i lost weight, a lot of it. borderling too much. i'm 'normal' now, or even thin. but i have cellulite, and stetch marks, and a poochy belly... what i'm trying to say is i've never seen a woman who looks like me portrayed as sexy, either. i wonder what it would be like to not see those ads as a personal critique...
and i agree, the hard things are so much less than the joy, but still tiring. you've been really inspiring to me. thank you.

2:11 PM  

Post a Comment

Links to this post:

Create a Link

<< Home